Skip to main content

Michael Masters - The Commodity Speculator Crusher?

Michael Masters, the hedge fund (Masters Capital Management LLC.) manager, made some headlines in the Hill and markets for his champions that speculators cause skyrocket high prices for commodities from agricultural grains to metal zinc. Media has raised the questions regarding Mr. Masters's motive because of his investments concentration in transportation. I pull out the his q2 13F regulatory filings via Bloomberg (see the chart below from Bloomberg), it is interesting to note that he increased weights on industries and utilities, two sectors by 6.1% and 5.8% respectively over 1st q this year. Not surprisingly, two of his top 5 holdings, Delta and US Ariways, make up 33% portfolio. During the quarter, US Airways positions were increased from 2 millions to 4 millions shares, and Delta was almost double the positions too (from 1.05 to 2 millions shares.) I guess the pain must be unbearable when the benchmark crude rocked to over $140 from less than $100 during the quarter. Certainly it is not his best interest to see crude oil going higher and stay there.




On the surface, Masters's conflict interest certainly does not serve him well in the argument. But then we can not ignore the fact that commodity market dynamic have evolved in terms of market participants and operations. I have serious doubts when a single factor or variable was cited as the cause or reason for price movement in equity or commodity markets, or any other form capital markets. There is no question that speculation/investment in commodities, more precisely, the rising demand from alternative investment vehicles (physical commodities and related instruments) since late 90's, have morphed commodities from dull pure raw material that was driven by supply-demand and economic cycle into something more "magic" investment instruments with a great potential appreciation. We would expect that commodities were primarily driven by supply-demand when the market participants were dominated by producers and end-users a decade ago, but commodities have draw more financial institution investors and speculators. For example, the total contracts of crude oil futures from speculators doubled to about 400,000 in early 2004 from the end of 2001, and over 800,000 in early 2006 and doubled again to over 1,600,000 early this year (see the chart below.) The dismissals of increasing speculation activities in commodity market and its impacts on the extreme violent movements of commodity at least in the short term, probably overlooked the simple facts. The question is not if but how to quantify the impacts. But history has demonstrated repeatedly that government intervention is wrong medicine for curing oil dependence.












Labels:

Popular posts from this blog

Updated: Will AAPL be $125-150 by July?

In late March, we saw significant bullish bets on AAPL in option markets. In my post " Will AAPL be $125-150 by July ?", we noticed a huge call spread position (10,000 contract) hit the tape on March 25. AAPL was closed at 106 and change, and has rallied more than 35%, which certainly make the owner of this long bull spread position smile proudly. So how much profit we are looking at right now if the investor exits the position today? At this moment, AAPL July 125 call is traded at about $19.50 and July 150 call around $4.20. Ignoring the transaction cost, each contract is worth about $1,530, so the total position is $15,300,000. Remembering that the initial investment was only about $3,950,000, and so net profit would be $11,350,000. The trade almost triples the initial investment just over two months! Not a small feast considering the limited risk profile.
Read more

Speculators Held Highest Net Long S&P Futures

Today's dramatic 1000 point reversal of Dow 30 may be just the capitulation point that market has been looking for in this free fall market. Many other sentiment indicators, such as AAII bull and bear readings, VIX and 52 week high/low also point to the extremes. Underneath this gloomy and Armageddon scenario, one of most significant and interesting piece of data is in the futures market, specifically speculator's reading in this scary market. According to today's data release from CFTC, it looks that speculators have positioned for market (S&P500) turnaround. As this past Tuesday, speculators have built more than 102,000 long S&P500 positions, a highest in last five years. More importantly, the speculators also have reduced the bearish bet, short positions to just about 43,000, a lowest level in two years. Without questions, in the last few weeks, the equity market was the darkest period for the long side, but the end may be in sight at least in the short term. Th...
Read more

Negative Swap Spread

One of most intriguing event, which barely got any attention in the market, was that, for the first time in the history, 30 year USD swap spread dropped into negative territory today. The US treasury 30 year bond traded at 4.027% and the same maturity US dollar swap traded at 4.051%, i.e, 30 year swap spread was about -2.4 bps (see attached Bloomberg chart below) . The 30 year swap rate only go back to early 1994 in Bloomberg data base, in the last 14 years, swap curve was always and should traded at discount to the treasury benchmark, "risk-free" bogey. So what is mean for the equity and credit market? Or most importantly, is the swap market trying or pricing the much deep recession or an early signal of Japanese-style deflation market has feared in 2003? Is the US treasury credit quality put into challenges? Or just the abnormally due to temporary market forces? Isn't the market facing the greatest CREDIT crisis we ever face since the Great Depression? Should we expect...
Read more